Controlling Parenting Could Create Problems for Kids

Authoritarian parents can damage their child's independence and breed disrespect, a study finds. Learn why – and how to loosen the reins a bit.

Controlling Parents

Fan of the iron fist? Turns out a parenting style some moms and dads consider the best might actually be the worst in the long run.

Authoritarian parents who employ the strict “my way or the highway” tactic at home are more likely to raise disrespectful and delinquent kids, reveals a new study by the University of New Hampshire – titled “Don’t Trust Anyone Over 30.”

Turns out adolescents with controlling parents are often defiant and lack trust in their parents, the study says. Researchers also found that the controlled kids exhibit delinquent behavior because they don’t see their parents as “legitimate authority figures.”

So, as a parent, what can you do to empower your children and gain their respect? Here’s how to demolish the authoritarian parenting style and build a healthy, trusting relationship with your children.

Why some parenting styles aren’t working

UNH researchers used data from an ongoing survey of middle- and high-school students to study what stokes delinquency. Over 18 months, they derived new details about the three major parenting styles: authoritarian, authoritative and permissive.

According to the study – the first to examine if certain parenting styles affect a kid’s behavior and a view of his parents – permissives don’t place enough boundaries for their children.

“These parents tend to produce children who are the least self-reliant, explorative and self-controlled out of all the parenting styles,” a UNH media release about the study reports.

On the other hand, authoritarian parents were found to be too demanding and are often “detached and unreceptive to their children’s needs” because of the communication deficiency, the release says. This style “produces children who are discontent, withdrawn and distrustful,” the study concluded.

Ironically, controlling parents “actually reduce the likelihood of their children perceiving their authority as legitimate,” Rick Trinkner, lead researcher, explains in the release. “Adolescents from authoritarian parents are more likely to resist their parents’ attempts at socialization.”

The most successful style? Middle-of-the-road authoritative style, the study says. These parents were a balance of demanding and receptive to their children’s needs, resulting in kids who are self-reliant and content because their parents listen to their opinions, according to the release.

Give your kid the best childhood ever. It's all waiting in our FREE Bucket List for Kids: 101 Things Your Kids Should Do Before They Grow Up guide.
Download it for FREE right now!
BONUS: Get a FREE subscription to Metro Parent magazine for more tips and fun.

Why it’s important to loosen the reins and where to start

Barbara Nickel, a therapist and clinical social worker with a private practice out of Farmington Hills, says that being less controlling of your kids by allowing them to make their own decisions is key for adult development.

“It’s part of the separation process, allowing children to grow into adults,” she explains. “They have to learn to take control of their own behaviors to grow up, and the (controlling) parents don’t let their children pass through the stage of development necessary to make their own decisions – because they make their decisions for them.”

Nickel says the first thing an authoritarian parent has to do is recognize that they’re authoritarian – and ask themselves “what it is about them as parents that they feel the need to keep controlling their kids.”

The second step is working on changing the identified cause, which, for example, could be anxiety, she says.

Gain respect and help your children grow

An effective ways to gain your child’s trust is to “respect the child and where the child is in the developmental process,” Nickel says, “and work to allow them to pass through that stage of development.

“As kids get older, the parent has to remain a parent,” she continues, noting that parents can’t become their child’s friend. “But parents have to have communication with their kids regarding what are and what are not allowable behaviors.”

In addition to communication, Nickel advises that parents “give their children some latitude and allow them responsibilities,” such as borrowing the family car – but setting a curfew. Then, she says, parents should monitor how the child handles the responsibility.

“If the child displays that they have mastered the task you’ve given them and that they’re responsible with that, then you give them more freedom,” she says. “If they’re home by curfew, then you know you can give them a little space, and vice versa. If they don’t respect that, they’re not ready.”

 

Comments
  • Yes, I am not leaving a reply but, I that I can ask a question and ther is someone who can text me and give us some ideas,tools. We have our great neice and she is nine and we are help with her stealing, lying,back talking and bring sassy. The sad thing is that from birth until she was three, her mother would (at birth) take t her place to place and drop off to anyone and at times she would even leave her in her car seat and find a house that was empty and leave there and, I can’t even count how many times she moved, in fact I never knew where she was. As times went on and my neice was tossed back and both between mother and grandmother. Then I am thinking it was about that age that the mother decided that she is going to move from California to Texas and with no plans and were they going to live. I can remember the day before they were going to move. The mother and grandmother came in to see me because I had asked them if they would because, I had something that I wanted to give my neice. My neice never had any toys so, I gave her a dolly and hope that her mother would be sure that could play with it. When mother and daughter gets to Texas she decided that she would just drop off at Aunt house and then her boyfriend and herself took off and then she would come back that, went on for a while. I also forgot to mention that she also just had a bay. I am try to shorten this story . At the time that mother was in her care she had feed my neice one hot dog a day and the baby got one bottle a day and the reason she had was that, she didn’t want them to get fat and also showed my neices hair and her reason was that she didn’t want to have to do her hair. My sister in law called the chp. Make this short but it leads up to the problem we have. As everything is going on the grandmother decided to move to Texas. So what happens is the mother gave her rights to her mom and takes off and of course her and boyfriend did some crime in fact it was happen in quite few states and they caught and go to prison. So at this point grandmother has only tone of the girls and the new baby was handed over to supposedly to the father of the baby. Ok this is where things start to get ugly. The grandmother already had the oldest daughter and always had because the mom gave all rights over to her mouth. The sad thing is is that she did not care for my neice, which of course is her granddaughter. The sad thing is she really never care for her. The rest of the family always thought it was because my neice always got a lot attention from strangers saying how cute she is and the older didn’t get that the attention that grandma though she have gotten so then she told my neice too call her by her name and not grandma both of my sisters in laws treat my neice awful in fact I called it abuse. My sisters in law would take make her go out side and then lock the door and they wouldn’t even let her come in to potty ( at that time she was being potty trained) they would just leave her out there and would wet her panties and, they don’t care and at times they would put a diaper on her and she would ever fall asleep outside. I could tell you so so many things that was done to my neice but, it would take some time. Then one day just out of the blues my sister in law which, is the grandmother and calls me and, said “I have a question for you you and you don’t have to answer now. So she finally gets what she wanted to ask. She ask would I take her granddaughter because she can’t handle her and also told me that she has beaten her until she was black and blues ( my mouth dropped and I wanted to cry) I said what is going on and she said that her granddaughter is too much to handle. I know the reason she did not love her. So my sister in law said think about and talk too her brother about it and, I said I will take her and then she has the balls and ask so when do you think that you can come and get her. I said I have too talk with your brother because, he will need to take time off. So I called him tell him everything and of course he says I am going to see how soon I can take off. So we go to get her and the first thing my neice said too me was I get to go home with you and she had the biggest smile on Horace, the sad part she didn’t even remembered who I was. So we spent the night and I ask for a book so that I could make here fell comfortable with me. My sister in law says we don’t have books. I thought wow that is really sad but my brother in law found an book. It was a book for a fourth grader but I made it work. I will say my brother in law loved that little girl so much that when it was time to leave he was the only that cried. The day we left our neice was so happy that she didn’t even she’d a tear and like said the only one cried was my brother in law. As were riding in the car and I was sitting in the back with her, we had my husband brother and his go with us so I sat in the back with her and, she would grab my hand and calls me mom and said I love you. I have to say that broke my heart and brought tears to my eyes. As time has gone on this little three year old sits up in her car seat and said ” thank you for taking me home with you guys ” oh boy did that even made want to cry. Time goes on and she would tell us so many times that she is so happy that we save her. My neice express many things that happen to her. For the first month we don’t have any problems and then, one day it was like the light switch over. She became where she would not listen and get in our faces and scream at us she would tear things up. She would hit me and bite me and scream top of her lungs for no reason and when want her to do something she so say no and she would come at you and she would bite or what ever she was thinking. We alway would so her affection and always telling her that how much we love her . We was very special careful on what battles to take on. We would if we had to discipline her we would put her in time out and the was a big battle. She would hoard her food and I cat remember the first time that went to Target and we bought her some popcorn and something to drink antifreeze a popcorn would fall on the floor she would pick up and eat it and we would catch her eating out of trash cans I am trying to get to the question but I think some of might be why does the thinos that she does. So time goes were in about having her for two months and it was getting worse. We have two kids and we never ever deal with the problems that our necice was acting out and this all is going on our daughter would take her with her to fro that had kids and our daughter was enjoying it and our necice started to call our daughter mom. As time goes by by I couldn’t handle her, I have lupus and fibermaogly and it was really effecting my health and I felt that o wasn’t going to be fair to our necice so I told my husband I ant do it I do think that we was going to have so problems like we’re having and we have no clue what to do. She needs some one that is knowable with the problems we are dealing with and isn’t fair to her and so I would never ever to that I waold say I give up but it wasn’t working and I am doing the right way to handle a and kid with the problems she has. If we had her when she was an infant where we could have her not gone throttle things that she had gone through and has effected her and we just don’t have the knowledge tha we need to get her help and have a good life. So our dat say she will do it that she loved so much and that she she is younger and has friends we kids that she is willing to other so she has guardian ship and now as time been going on our necice has gotten out of control and one daughter has been take to see some one. She steals lies and back talks and by rude so our quest is what do we do because who she is seeing isn’t do angry to help and out Daisha’s done everything she can do and it hasn’t work. Please text 209 345 1637 and give us some ideas . Sorry for the grammar and spelling but I have so much in my that I am trying to get out and do I just tattoo and not think that I am not sing the grammar and spelt thanks for who ever texts me back thanksgivings

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Enter Your Log In Credentials
×
Enter Your Log In Credentials
×