How to Win Toddler Arguments

Defuse disputes with your defiant tot with these nine tips from a local certified parent coach.

Babies’ first words are cute – until they master “no” and “why.” But your tyke isn’t out to out-debate you. “All children want a certain amount of independence,” explains Barbara Bushey, a certified parent coach based in South Lyon, and they’re willing to “argue with their parents to get (it).” Here’s how you and your defiant toddler can keep calm.

1. Avoid duel meltdowns. The tantrum is a spectacle, Bushey says – one best ignored. If you give in, you tell your child, “If I want something, if I lay down on the floor and scream and holler,” the magic will happen.

2. Don’t dodge questions. Yes, kids use them as stall tactics, but remember: They’re naturally inquisitive. Feeding kids as much information at an age-appropriate level as possible “shows respect to the child.” If the child questions a chore, you can say, “It’s part of being a family. Everyone has something that they have to do.”

3. Build routines. Tykes won’t retain routines at 2, but by 4, they’ll begin to remember, “Before I eat dinner, I have to put away my toys.” They’re less likely to fight ingrained norms.

4. Don’t reward requested behaviors. Verbal praise is the best, Bushey says. For instance: “I’m so glad you’re being responsible at getting up on time and getting ready for school. That makes me really proud of you.”

5. Avoid ‘wishy-washy’ language. “Never ask ‘would you like to’ if they’re going to have to. You would say, ‘You must go to bed now’ – not ‘I think it’s time to go to bed.’ You’ve got be direct with them.”

6. Don’t sweat it. Some fights aren’t worth twisted arms. “If it’s not dangerous, let them take the consequences of their actions.” Rebels who refuse to wear socks will tire of blisters.

7. Keep calm and don’t carry on. “Children do what we do, not what we say,” Bushey says. “If you’re arguing, fighting, bickering – that’s what you’re modeling.” Build in breaks too. “Just yelling at them only causes them to yell louder; then you yell louder, and it just gets into this shouting match that doesn’t help.”

8. Consider age. Sometimes, you “could be asking your child to do something that’s developmentally inappropriate for their age,” Bushey says. In these cases, “they start to develop this opinion, ‘I’m no good. I can’t do anything.'” If your child feels stupid, he or she won’t motivated by instruction.

9. No, no, NO. Got a persistent case? “I will ask why they are saying no,” Bushey says. “If it’s just because they don’t want to do it, then I explain to them that this is part of what they need to do (as a member of the family) and they need to do it.” If they still refuse, “They may get five minutes in the thinking chair.”

Illustration by Mary Kinsora


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -


What Every Kid Should Get for the Holidays This Year

When friends and family ask what your children want this year, experts suggest asking them to invest in your child's college future. It may not have the dazzle of the latest toy or gadget, but it will have value that lasts a lifetime.

Best Sledding Hills in Metro Detroit

When it snows, a-sledding we will go.

How to Set Good Money Examples for Kids

Your money-related actions and conversations can model positive behaviors for kids, from toddlers to teenagers.

Plan Early and Include Family to Reduce Student Loan Debt for Your Child

Discover why opening a Michigan 529 when your child is young can help reduce debt in the long run.

- Advertisement -